Skip to Main Content

WRT 101S - Desert Vista -Evaluating Sources: SIFT EXAMPLE

SIFT QUIZ (SEE IMAGE BELOW)

SIFT Method:

  • STOP - open another window and go to Google.com.
  • INVESTIGATE the Source - A google search for this site reveals information from a variety of sources (such as Wikipedia, GLAAD, and WIRED) stating that the American College of Physicians is socially conservative, and/or an anti-LGBTQ group - and is designated a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center.
  • FIND Other Coverage - An alternative organization from the search is the American Academy of Pediatrics. A Google search of this organization doesn't reveal anything alarming.
  • TRACE Claims to Original Context - One statement on the website is as follows:  “[Gender/transition affirming health care] is neither proven effective nor safe long term, does not reduce suicides, and is not the standard of care for gender dysphoria.” However, a search in PubMed reveals research studies published in medical and psychology journals that find that gender-affirming care does decrease chances of depression and suicide in patients.
     

Which source is biased toward one point of view according to the SIFT test?

Pediatric Organizations - Which one is a credible site?

American Academy of Pediatrics | Itasca IL

 

The American College of Pediatricians (@ACPeds) / Twitter